I am in love with Bobbi Brown’s classic cream eye shadow pots and decided to also try the cream shadow stick, thinking that it would be a very similar product. These are great because they can be used as an eyeshadow base or on its own.
Although the cream shadow stick is similar, it is not as good as the classic cream shadow pots in my opinion. The wearability is fine but there is some creasing on the lids if this product is worn alone rather as an eye shadow base. The pots on the other hand offer MUCH better setting on the eyelids, it actually dries very quickly so you have to work fast! The colour also does not fade and stays in place all day, literally!
The up-side to the stick is definitely the convenience of not needing to use a brush, but I think all considering I would rather stick with the original cream shadows.