Faking happiness

Tuesday, 20 March 2012

Faking happinessIn the last decade, there has been a major shift in how psychologists look at emotions. With the birth of ‘positive psychology’, the focus has moved from negative feelings and how those feature within the context of mental illness, to the mechanisms that cause and sustain happiness.

The field is a strange, paradoxical marriage between the entirely objective – science – and the entirely subjective – happiness. It is a domain full of complexities, contentions and confusion – for one thing, pinning down an exact definition of happiness is no easy task. ‘It’s difficult to define happiness, as there are so many facets to it,’ says Cape Town psychiatrist Dr Liz Legg. ‘Pleasure, engagement, accomplishments, relationships, physical health, meaning and purpose – all of these play a part in the level of happiness people experience.’

Given the blurriness around the concept itself, it’s not surprising that controversy also rages around what gives rise to and influences feelings of wellbeing. One debate is whether ‘happiness causes happiness’, as many in the field of positive psychology claim. This idea was sparked by a famous German study in 1988, in which researchers required subjects to hold a pencil between either their teeth or their lips, forming either a smile or a frown, and then rated them on a humour scale while watching cartoons. The researchers found that those subjects who were involuntarily smiling as they used their teeth found the cartoons funnier, which led them to conclude that the physical act of smiling – even if faked – can trigger a release of ‘feel-good’ chemicals into the brain.

Since then, several other studies have garnered support for the idea that acting happy can get you closer to the real thing, with some researchers citing the role of neural pathways as a reference. Think of the way in which drops of water tend to run down the same trickle path – so too, does the energy flowing through our brains tend to travel down the pathways which offer the least resistance. In other words, the more we think negatively, the more habitual those thoughts become and the more they translate into feelings of unhappiness. To break entrenched patterns of negativity, we need to direct our thoughts along more positive pathways, effectively rewiring our brains, say many scientists.

But in the last few years a burgeoning backlash against the idea of faked happiness has emerged, with recent research indicating that forced demonstrations of positivity can elevate stress levels and do damage to both mental and physical health. For instance, a 2006 study of customer service representatives by scientists at the University of Frankfurt am Main found that those who were forced to be friendly and polite during phone calls had a higher risk of depression and cardiovascular disease.

Research conducted by the University of Michigan in 2011 sheds a little more light on the subject. In this study, researchers followed bus drivers over a period of two weeks, investigating what happened when they engaged in ‘surface acting’ (fake smiles and friendliness) and ‘deep acting’, when they generated true smiles through positive memories, thoughts, or affirmations.

They found that on days the drivers’ smiles were forced, they tended to experience an increase in negativity and withdraw from work, while on days their smiles were underscored by genuine feelings of positivity, their productivity and level of engagement improved, along with their general mood.

This seems to suggest that faking happiness only has any real benefit for the individual is there is some authentic basis to it. If accompanied by feelings of resentment or anger, it appears to do more harm than good – perhaps because energy is still being pumped down the same old negative pathways.

Written by

After spending most of the last decade working as a journalist and editor in Thailand and travelling the East, Cindy returned to the Mother City in September 2010. She has written for a wide spectrum of online and offline publications in both South Africa and SE Asia and is passionate about reading, writing, food, globe-trotting and cats.

Want to write a comment? Sign in here sign up now
Tell your friends
  1. Pseudo_kate

    very interesting. I’m not too sure about some of this research though.

    6 years ago •

  1. me

    It’s like a salesmen trying to make if they believe in what they sell -unconvincing Compared to one who really believes what they sell.

    6 years ago •

  1. Sam

    I think that there’s some truth in this study.

    7 years ago •

BeautySouthAfrica - your pre-shop stop for all things beauty

Beautysouthafrica.com is South Africa’s most comprehensive online beauty magazine and your pre-shop stop for product information and reviews. From the latest international make-up trends to the hottest new products on the market, we offer insights into the glamorous world of beauty. Join like-minded beauty fanatics in our loyalty program and earn points, trial beauty products and share your experiences.

Become a beauty addict!

Get great deals and climb the ladder to a Gold Star!


Sign In