im very impressed ! this is a nice product,and i think its similiar to the bobbi brown gel eyeliner and its way more affordable.I love the container and you also get a nice stiff brush that comes along with it.This gel eyeliner goes on very nice,i like the dark colour-it stays dark and i really have to remove it with makeup remover.It last very long.i will definitely repurchase this again.Maybelline’s got a winner here!