I tried the shade “Indian Pink” which showed up on my lips as a slightly dark plum. The colour of this liner is beautiful and would suit a multitude of different skin tones. The liner is packaged as a normal wooden pencil liner is and it carries a typical scent of wood. Application was easy as the liner formula is very creamy and has great pigmentation. Even though the texture is creamy, the liner can feel a bit dry which is common with pencil liners. The colour did not transfer, but it also didn’t last very long on my lips after eating, drinking, etc. Personally, I prefer retractable liners as I find sharpening pencils a schlep especially when it is a colour I would gravitate to regularly. The shade “Indian Pink” is a must especially for those who love wearing bold and hot pink lipstick shades.