This is a truly amazing mascara! It has beautiful lengthening and volumising effects and the brush is just perfect!
The problem is that I found it smudged TERRIBLY on me. And I don’t mean the slight smudging when blinking right after applying, I mean it smudged ALL DAY… To the point when I had black marks under my eyes all the time and needed to self consciously check the mirror and wipe away residue the whole day!
This could be because I am lucky enough to have long lashes which make contact with skin with my facial expressions, but this was really less than ideal for someone who already suffers from dark circles…
I had to give up on this mascara… I am now using Bobbi Brown Smokey Eye mascara and it has changed my life! No smudging at all, even though it isn’t waterproof.