When I first bought this product I was very happy with the results! So it’s a two in one eyeliner. The side with the thin eyeliner, similar to most eyeliners, was great to fill in my lids. While the other side with the thicker and slightly angled liner was good to create the perfect wing with! It was a beautiful black that dries to a matt finish, which I love. So basically the perfect product right? My only problem is that the pigment of the liner faded with time, later causing patchy lines which is really hard to work with. Started off great, but pigment faded with time for some reason.