I received this eyeliner in green to review. I was a bit skeptical about green as I have brown eyes. The colour itself was great and quite subtle. I was not too happy about the application as the tip is soft you are unsure of how much product is being distributed and it took me a few tries to get it right. I still prefer the hard tips. All in all I doubt I would be purchasing it. I think it is overpriced and the application needs some work.