I love a good liquid liner, and this one did not disappoint. I used the shade “Midnight Blue” which I initially thought looked black on my eyelids, but upon closer inspection I saw it was a very dark navy blue. I have also used the black one in the past, and found it was great for a subtle cat eye. It applied easily and there was no smudging, running or skipping. It lasted for most of the day, but the inner and outer corners had disappeared by 5pm, and I had to touch up before dinner. Overall I think it is well-priced and good value for money.