I have pale lashes and can’t go without mascara, have to wear brown so always in search of a mascara, often brown gets discontinued. Last time I was hunting the assistant at Woolworths showed me Yves Rocher Sexy Pulp Mascara which I hadn’t tried before. At R185 it was worth trying. The liquid is very smooth no clumps, love the colour, really nice brush which combs the lashes beautifully. Lasts all day and washes off easily with aqueous cream or cleanser. Going back to get another tube :)