I’m sorry to hear of your predicament. I’m not really familiar with the Garnier Range. If it’s really a case that you want to specifically carry on with their products, why don’t you go onto their website and log a customer enquiry? That way they will be able to tell you if there is a replacement product fro the one that you like so much. My area of expertise is the medical products and cosmeceuticals which are much more active that the "over the counter” products, so I’m sorry I’m not really able to give you an alternative cosmetic. If you’d like to think about starting off on a really good cosmeceutical, then I would suggest you start with Nimue or Neostrata.